The NuDoubt++ Experiment


Understanding Double Beta Decay

Certain isotopes are inherently unstable, causing their nuclei to break apart through nuclear decay. Imagine a nucleus as a tiny, densely packed space filled with positively charged protons and neutral neutrons. For an element to stay stable, the ratio of neutrons to protons must be just right. This delicate balance is why some isotopes are stable while others become radioactive. Radioactivity, as the name suggests, involves the spontaneous emission of radiation. An unstable atomic nucleus releases energy (carried away by emitted particles) to achieve a more stable state.

There are various forms of radioactive decay, each involving the emission of different combinations of particles. One fascinating example of this transformation is double beta decay. It’s a rare process where an atom’s nucleus changes to become more stable. During this change, the nucleus emits two tiny particles (beta particles) and two almost invisible particles ((anti)neutrinos). A beta particle is essentially an electron or positron that’s emitted from the nucleus. Neutrinos are incredibly light, neutral particles that interact very weakly with matter, making them difficult to detect but they are crucial for balancing the energy and momentum in nuclear reactions.

Beta decays
Illustration of beta decay processes. In beta plus (β⁺) decay (left), a proton in the nucleus decays into a neutron and a positron (a positively charged electron), which is subsequently emitted from the nucleus along with neutrino. In beta minus (β⁻) decay (right), a neutron within the nucleus converts into a proton, electron, and an antineutrino. In double beta decay, two neutrons or two protons decay at the same time. © V. Palušová, JGU

Scientists like to study this because it helps them understand more about how the tiniest parts of the universe work.

Double beta decay is extremely rare, with half-lives ranging from 1018 to 1024 years - far longer than the age of the universe, which is approximately 1010 years! This means that the atoms undergoing this decay do so very slowly. Observing double beta decay in a laboratory setting is challenging and requires highly enriched radioactive materials and advanced detection equipment.

Physicist Maria Goeppert-Mayer first predicted double beta decay in 1935. It wasn’t observed until 1987 when scientists Steven R. Elliott, Alan A. Hahn, and Michael K. Moe successfully detected it in a sample of selenium-82.

Modes of Double Beta Decay

  1. Two-Neutrino Double Beta Decay (2νββ):
    • In this process, two (anti)neutrinos are released along with the beta particles. This has been observed in different types of nuclei.
  2. Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay (0νββ):
    • In this mode, no neutrinos are emitted.

    While neutrinoless double beta decay is a fascinating hypothesis, scientists are still working to observe it. Detecting it would be a major breakthrough because it would show that total number of leptons (particles like electrons and neutrinos) isn’t always conserved. This could reveal new things about neutrinos, possibly showing that they are their own antiparticles and helping us learn more about their masses.

Double beta decays
Illustration of double beta decay and neutrinoless double beta decay. In standard double beta decay (left), two neutrons within a nucleus convert into two protons, emitting two electrons (beta particles) and two electron antineutrinos (ν̅). This process, known as double beta minus (β⁻β⁻) decay, increases the atomic number (Z) by two, transforming the nucleus into a new element. Conversely, in double beta plus (β⁺β⁺) decay, two protons convert into two neutrons, emitting two positrons and two neutrinos (ν). In neutrinoless double beta decay (right), the hypothetical process involves the conversion of two neutrons (protons) into two protons (neutrons) with the emission of only two electrons (positrons), without any accompanying neutrinos. © V. Palušová, JGU

A lot of work has gone into studying the process, where two electrons are emitted, and the nucleus changes by converting two neutrons into two protons, increasing its charge by two units.

However, this is just one part of the story. There are other intriguing modes of double beta decay that decrease the nuclear charge number:

  • Double Positron Decay (2β+): Two protons in the nucleus change into two neutrons, releasing two positrons.
  • Positron-Emitting Electron Capture (ECβ+): One proton turns into a neutron by emitting a positron, while another proton captures an electron and becomes a neutron.
  • Double Electron Capture (2EC): Two protons in the nucleus each capture an electron and transform into two neutrons.

Among these, only double electron capture (2ν2EC) has been observed while the others remain elusive.

2ν2EC
In 2ν2EC, two protons in a nucleus are simultaneously transformed into neutrons by absorbing two electrons from one of the atomic shells and emitting two electron neutrinos (ν). This process primarily involves capturing electrons from the K shell. The atomic shell is left in an excited state with two vacancies in the K shell leading to the production of a detectable cascade of X-rays and Auger electrons as the resulting vacancies are filled during atomic relaxation. © V. Palušová, JGU

Research into these decay processes is driven by advances in our understanding of the underlying physics that governs double beta decay. Data from double beta decay experiments help refine our theories about nuclear structure. Scientists are particularly excited about the possibility of observing neutrinoless positron-emitting processes. These could allow researchers to test and differentiate between theories beyond the Standard Model of particle physics, potentially uncovering new physics by revealing signs of lepton number violation.

Unraveling these elusive decay processes might just turn out to be the key to unlocking the universe’s best-kept secrets - one particle at a time.

The NuDoubt++ Experiment in a Nutshell

The NuDoubt++ experiment is focused on exploring a very rare nuclear process called double beta plus decay, which involves the release of two positrons (particles similar to electrons but with a positive charge). Detecting this decay is quite difficult due to its rarity, the challenging nature of its detection, and the scarcity of suitable materials for study. To overcome these challenges, we propose a unique detector that combines advanced technologies to improve the chances of identifying these rare events.

What We Aim to Achieve

With our new detector, we expect to identify double beta plus decay events after just one week of operation with one tonne of material. Moreover, we hope to greatly improve the detection limits for an even rarer process known as neutrinoless double beta plus decay.

Why It Matters

The search for neutrinoless double beta decay is crucial because it could reveal whether neutrinos (particles that are everywhere but hard to detect) are their own antiparticle. Current experiments have set impressive limits, but to answer this big question, we need to make even more sensitive measurements. This requires larger experiments with better energy resolution and cleaner detection methods. Our NuDoubt++ detector is designed to meet these needs.

The NuDoubt++ Prototype

We propose to build a cylindrical detector prototype that uses about one metric tonne of a special scintillator material (a substance that emits light when it absorbs particles). This material helps us to distinguish between different types of particles based on how they emit light. The detector is equipped with advanced light sensors to measure energy and position precisely, allowing us to test our particle discrimination methods.

Our Goals

Our detector is designed to measure rare double beta decays and set new limits for these processes. We are particularly interested in studying isotopes like Kr-78, Xe-124, and Cd-106. If we succeed, it would represent the discovery of some of the rarest decay processes known in physics. Eventually, we plan to use this prototype in an underground facility to search for these rare decays with even higher sensitivity.

How Our Detector Works

Hybrid Scintillator: This technology uses the ratio of two types of light (Cherenkov and scintillation light) to distinguish between particles. Massive particles produce less Cherenkov light, while positrons produce less Cherenkov light compared to electrons.

Opaque Scintillator: This technique confines light within the detector, allowing us to collect detailed information about where and how particles interact with the detector material. This helps us to differentiate between electrons, gamma rays, and positrons.

By combining these two techniques, we enhance our ability to reject background signals and accurately identify the rare decays we are looking for.

Advanced Light Collection: We use Optimised Wavelength-shifting optical fibers (OWL-fibers) to improve light collection efficiency. These fibers are designed to capture more photons, enhancing the performance of our detector. Initial tests show promising results, and we are continually working to improve this technology.

Stay tuned for more updates and results from the NuDoubt++ experiment as we continue our research and development efforts!

Glossary

Elementary particle - An elementary particle is a fundamental building block of matter that cannot be broken down into smaller components. Think of it as the tiniest piece of a puzzle that makes up everything around us. For example, electrons and quarks are elementary particles that combine to form atoms, which in turn make up all the objects and substances we encounter daily.

Antiparticle - An antiparticle is like a mirror image of a regular particle. It has the same mass as its counterpart but opposite electrical charge and other properties. For example, if you have an electron with a negative charge, its antiparticle, called a positron, has a positive charge. When a particle meets its antiparticle, they can cancel each other out in a burst of energy, a process known as annihilation.

Neutrino - A neutrino is an almost invisible particle that is extremely difficult to detect because it rarely interacts with other matter. It has no electrical charge and a very small mass, making it elusive and able to pass through most materials, including the Earth, almost undisturbed. Neutrinos are produced in large numbers in processes like nuclear reactions in the sun or nuclear reactors.

Cherenkov light - Cherenkov light is a type of light that is produced when a charged particle, such as an electron, travels through a medium (like water or glass) faster than the speed of light in that medium. This causes a shockwave of light, similar to a sonic boom, which appears as a faint blue glow. It’s commonly observed in nuclear reactors and used in particle detectors to help identify high-speed particles.

Scintillator - A scintillator is a special material that emits flashes of light when it absorbs particles. This light can then be detected and measured to determine the presence and energy of the incoming particle. Scintillators are used in various scientific and medical applications, such as detecting radiation in cancer treatments or in experiments to explore fundamental particles.

Optical fiber - An optical fiber is a thin, flexible strand made of glass or plastic that transmits light from one end to the other. It's like a super-thin pipe that guides light, allowing it to travel long distances with minimal loss. Optical fibers are used in many technologies, including internet cables, medical instruments, and lighting systems, to carry information or light efficiently.